233 EPIDURAL HAEMATOMA A RETROSPECTIVESTUDYOF C. Jonker,* looPATIENTS and H. J. 0osterhui.P” SUMMARY A retrospective study was made of 100 consecutive patients with an epidural haematoma in order to establish which clinically demonstrable factors had influenced the prognosis quoad vitam et sanationem. Operations were performed on 92 of these patients, 29 (32%~) of whom died; 8 patients died without operation, and in 2 of these cases the diagnosis was not made during life. A lucid interva1 was observed in 57 patients; absence of a lucid interval in combination with a lowered sensory ievel indicated associated intradural lesions (cerebral contusion, acute subdural haematoma), with consequently a less good prognosis. The prognosis was also adversely affected by deeper coma, occurrence of extensor spasms, bilateral stiff pupils, bilateral pyramidal symptoms and an age over 50. Some 330/o of the patients treated by operation showed marked symptoms of compression (extensor spasms and/or bilateral stiff pupils); although these symptoms are usually described as indicative of a hopeless prognosis, 400/o of the patients in this catagory survived. Contrary to the data in the literature, the interval between accident and operation within the first 24 hours did not influence the mortality, which was 500/o. All patients operated on more than 24 hours after the accident, survived. A cranial fracture was absent in 13 patients, 11 of whom were under 30; absence of a cranial fracture was prognostically favourable. A catamnestic study revealed that 7 of the 58 accessible survivors had residual neurological dysfunctions; all these patients were up and about. The residual morbidity after early operalion (within 24 hours) was the same as that after later operation. The data obtained were compared with those on a number of series recently published in the literature. INTRODUCTION Epidurat haematoma is a vitally dangerous complication in a small proportion of patients with head injuries. The literature reports that it occurs in 1.530/o of all clinically observed patients with a head injury (MCKISSOCK, TAYLOR, BLOOM, TILL, 1960; JOSEPHSON, 1962; JAMIESON and YELLAND, 1968). A lowering of the level of consciousness after a short period of clear consciousness, unilateral pupillary dilatation and pupillary stiffness, and hemiparesis conFrom the Dept. of the Neurology, Wilhelmina Gasthuis, Amsterdam, The Netherlands. * Present address: Valerius kliniek, Dept. of Psychiatry, Amsterdam, The Netherlands. ** Present address: Dept. of Neurology, University Hospital, Groningen, The Netherlands. Clin. Nemo]. Neurosurg. 1975-4 234 tralateral to the pupillary dilatation constitute the classic triad of symptoms which facilitate diagnosis. Since surgical treatment is not difficult either, the prognosis of an epidural haematoma diagnosed early ought to be favourable. However, in recent series of more than 100 patients the mortality varies from 1Y/U to 25@.‘~ (MCKISSOCK et al, 1960; JAMIESON et al, 1968). In this study we raise the question as to which clinically demonstrable factors influenced the prognoses quoad vitam and quoad sanationem in a consecutive series of 100 patients presented in the neurological and neurosurgical departments of the Wilhelmina Gasthuis, Amsterdam, between 1961 and 1973. PATIENTS AND METHODS selective of patients Working back from 1973, all case histories of patients with an anatomically verified diagnosis of epidural haematoma were lifted from the files until a total of 100 was attained. We excluded patients with an impression fracture of the skull, with an abnormal bleeding tendency, and with severe extracranial injuries. The diagnosis had been made at operation in 92 patients, and at a postmortem without preceding operation in 8. Patients who showed cerebral contusion in addition were ltut excluded. The series comprised 81 males and 19 females, admitted between 1961 and 1973, for the most part directly to the neurosurgical clinic (Head Prof. Dr. W. Noordenbos). A traffic accident was involved in 63 cases. The group with an epidurai haematoma amounted to about 3o/0 of the total number of patients admitted to the neurological and neurosurgical departments of the Wilhelmina Gasthuis with a head injury during this period. Owing to the regional function of the neurosurgical clinic, a proportion of patients came from other hospitals; 68 patients had had their accident in Amsterdam, and the remaining 32 within a radius of 60 km. Method and procedure On the basis of a coding scheme we studied a number of factors which, according to the literature and personal views, could have influenced the course. The data on the patient’s condition concerned the final examination prior to operation. Items studied were: age; occurrence of a so-called free interval (defined as sensory clearing which foIlowed an initial lowering of the level of co~scious~~s and in turn was foliowed by a lowering of the level of consciousness); variations in the level of consciousness; the interval between the accident and examination before operation; the level of consciousness before operation; occurrence of epileptic convulsions; occurrence of extensor spasms; pulse rate; blood pressure; 235 pupils; ocular fundi; pyramidal symptoms; shift of the midline echo and presence of a cranial fracture. Radiographs were not evaluated by the authors; only if the operation report as well as the radiological report mentioned no fracture was it assumed that no fracture was present. All patients who at the last clinical or out-patient follow-up still showed residual neurological changes were summoned and personally examined (so far as they were still living in The Netherlands). The data were transferred to punch cards and analysed by the Mechanical Administration Unit of the Wilhelmina Gasthuis. RESULTS The total mortality was 370/o and the mortality after operation was 32010. TABLE I Age, interval from accident to operation and mortality Interval from accident to operation 2-7 days alive first day age (Y) alive died o- 9 IO-19 20-29 30-39 40-19 50- 6 7 9 5 7 2 3 4 9 3 7 II 36 --____TABLE I 1 6 3 I I 3 _.... _.I---__ 37 .“___._____ _ _-_ B 8 days alive _ ._. _ I.5 2 2 4 3 _- --.. ._ I2 total ~._ II I9 23 13 I8 I6 100 2 Free interval and mortality ..~.________ Clear consciousness after initial coma Free interval Immediate coma without recovery ~~~ -__ -....~_ Total ._.-. total died 13 57 30 0 19 I8 100 37 _.~ _-..___ ___ .__~ __ Tables 1 and 2 relate age and free interval to survival. The mortality of patients whose accident had occurred in Amsterdam or within a radius of 25 km was about 300/o. But of the 9 patients who had to be transported over a distance exceeding 25 km, 7 died. Only 10 of the 34 patients who were comatose at the final examination before operation, survived. The chance of survival was significantly better when the response to pain stimuli was still intact (fig. I). 236 FIG.I Mortality and the level of consciousness before operation N q 40- ..‘:.:::g. :I.::.. .::. 2&g died 30- alive 20- 9 10- I I clear I. II III II responsive, but confused 111 non responsive, restless, reaction to pain IV no reaction to pain The pupils were examined in all patients. Of the 6 patients who survived despite bilateral pupillary dilatation and stiffness, 4 were under 30 (table 3). Two were operated on immediately after observation of these symptoms. The other two had no cranial fracture. TABLE 3 Pupil reactions and mortality Normal pupils Anisocoria Dilated pupils, unresponsive to light Total Extensor spasms were observed total died 30 44 26 3 14 20 100 37 in 28 patients, more than 500/o of whom were seen within 6 hours after the accident. The mortality in this group was considerable: 18 patients died. Extensor spasms and/or stiff pupils were found in 38 patients. Since the prognosis was considered hopeless, 8 patients were not operated on; all died. Of the 237 30 patients better treated by operation, in the 19 patients under 18 died. The prognosis 30, of whom was found 9 died, than not to be much in the 11 patients ovet 30, of whom 9 died (FISHER'S test: not significant). Hemipareses or other pyramidal symptoms were observed in 75 patients. In 6. the dysfunction was on the side of the haematoma; 4 of these patients developed the symptoms of haematoma within 2 hours of the accident. This contradicts the observations dysfunction reported by MCKISSOCK et al. (1960) who observed homolateral precisely in cases of chronic epidural haematoma (present longer than 7 days). Of the patients with bilateral pyramidal symptoms, 500/o died. Total areflexia was observed in 6 patients, of whom 5 died. An epileptic seizure was observed in only 2 of the 100 patients. Both patients were suffering from cerebral contusion as well, as established postmortem or at operation. In only 55 cases the ocular fundi were examined; choked disc was diagnosed in 24. In 3 patients this was observed within 4 hours of the accident, but the majority (13 of the 24 cases) were chronic epidural haematomas which had been present longer than 24 hours (in 9 of these 13 patients longer than 7 days). The pulse rate was recorded in 75 patients. A pulse rate < 60/min. was found in 24 patients (8 of whom died); 40 patients had a pulse rate of 6OlOO/min. (15 died), and 11 patients had a pulse rate > lOO/min. (9 died). Blood pressure values were available for only 52 patients. In 5 patients it was below RR 125/70 (2 died), in 32 it was 150-125 systolic and 90-70 diastolic (14 died); in 15 patients it was over 150/90 (9 died). No relation was established between mortality and blood pressure, but a rapid pulse seemed prognostically unfavourable. Radiography of the skull was carried out in 94 patients. In 13 patients a fracture was not found either radiologically or at operation (table 4). Of these 13 patients, I I were under 30. Absence of a cranial fracture substantially enhanced the chance of survival not only in the total group but also in the group under 30. Tile midline echo was studied in 70 patients and found to have shifted in 60. Of TABLE 4 Skull fracture and mortality under age 30 fracture total died total died 81 13 33 1 38 I1 13 absent unknown 6 3 4 2 100 37 53 I6 present I 238 the 10 patients without shift of the midline echo, 2 died. In the 60 patients with a shift there was no relation between the shift measured and the mortality, which in all groups was about 30Oi~ In 6 of the 10 patients without shift of the midline echo the haematoma had been present longer than 7 days. Within 8 hours of the injury more than 500/o of the patients developed symptoms of epidural haematoma (fig. II). The time factor refers to the duration of the interval between the injury and the exam~ation which led to operation. It is evident that the prognosis in the first 24 hours after the injury is not dependent on the interval. All patients in whom a haematoma was not diagnosed until 24 hours after the injury or later, remained alive. FIG. II Interval from accident to operation and mortality N 40 died 30 -27 alive cl 20 fC o-4 5-8 9-24 1OUfS In addition to epidural haematoma, operation or postmortem disclosed intradural lesions in 24 patients: subdural haematoma in 12, cerebral contusion with severe lacerations in 12. There have probably been more patients with lesions of brain tissue, because cerebral contusion was clinically diagnosed in a total of 38 patients. In a number of these patients there was no indication for opening the dura during the operation. As was more or less to be expected, not only the total mortality but also the postoperative mortality increased substantially in the presence of intradural Iesions (table 5). In 8 of the 24 patients with an intradural lesion, no operation but only a postmortem was performed. Of the remaining 16 who were submitted to operation, 10 died. 239 TABLE 5 Intradural lesions and mortality age --- with intradural total died lesions 10 16 19 12 12 7 2 2 7 2 3 3 1 3 4 1 6 9 i 2 2 1 4 8 76 19 24 18 ~~-~ o-9 IO-19 20-29 30-39 40-49 50. ‘CHRONIC’ without intradural lesions total died EPIDURAL HAEMATOMA The 27 patients whose operation took place 24 hours after the injury or later, all survived. Operation records showed that a micro-arterial haemorrhage had been observed in 6 patients and a tamponaded arterial haemorrhage in 3 patients, no bleeding artery having been found in 18. The symptoms which had prompted the diagnosis were generally based on increased intracranial pressure (choked disc, drowsiness, vomiting) and a shift of the midline echo. In 20 of the 27 patients neurological examination reveaIed no dysfunction or only one pathological plantar reflex. In 13 patients no free interval was observed and the sensory level had not been lowered after the initial loss of consciousness, The ‘acute’ and the ‘chronic’ cases did not differ in age distribution and preserice of a fracture. The residual morbidity was also the same for both groups. The interval between injury and operation can amount to several months, as the following case history (HM 15152) illustrates, Case history In June 1961 a 30-month-old girl feil down about 10 steps of a stairway. After a free interval of 3 hours she started vomiting and 10% consciousness for severaf hours. Once the sensory levef was restored to normal she showed left-sided hemiparesis whicn inciuded the facial muscles. The hemiparesis receded in the course of a week, and after 3 weeks she was free of symptoms. Cranial X-rays showed no fracture lines. The girl was discharged. At follow-up 4 months later the EEG showed fairly differentiated features on the left, but evidence of slight general suppression on the right. In view of this abnormal EEG she was seen again 6 months later. Because a nodule was palpable on the head, radiographs of the skull were obtained which revealed a fairly welldefined accumulation of calcium in the right parietal region (cf. photograph). 240 At operation a partly calcified epidural haematoma after the operation the EEC was symmetrical. was removed, and 6 monthly MORBIDITY morbidity in the 63 surviving patients was studied. Those already released from follow-up, or those who still complained of mild headaches and dizziness. were regarded as cured and not summoned to report for a follow-up. Investigation and case records revealed that only 4 patients were under treatment for epilepsy: in 3 of these the operation was more than 5 years ago, and in the 4th the followup covered a period of 18 months. The last out-patient or clinical follow-up had still revealed residual neurological changes in 17 patients, 4 of whom were foreigners who could not be summoned. Of the remaining 13, 1 failed to respond to the summons. Of the 12 patients finally seen, 7 showed neurological changes: spastic hemiparesis in 5, with dysphasia in 3; cerebellar aiaxia and dysarthria in 1; oculomotor paresis and hypaesthesia of the left side of the body in 1. We refrained from an evaluation of psychosocial aspects in these cases. In only 3 patients the follow-up period did exceed 5 years. A striking finding was that 4 of the 7 patients with residual symptoms had shown extensor spasms or bilateral pupillary stiffness when examined before operation. At operation only 1 of these 7 pattents was found to suffer from cerebral contusion. The FINDINGS IN EIGHT NON-SURGICAL PATIENTS A diagnosis of cerebral contusion was made in 3 patients. The postmortem revealed marked contusion with a subdural haematoma and a small epidural haernatoma. In one case epidural haematoma was diagnosed but an operation was reframed 241 from in view of the clinical pupils). The postmortem only a small epidural condition revealed haematoma. (bilateral contusion dilatation and with a large subdural In 1 patient the diagnosis stiffness of the haematoma and ‘epidural haematoma’ was considered but rejected in view of marked brain stem symptoms (tachycardia, pyrexia), symmetrical moderate dilatation and stiffness of the pupils, and some slight shift of the midline echo. The postmortem disclosed a large epidural haematoma with contrecoup contusion. In two cases the diagnosis was rejected on the basis of arteriographic findings interpreted as normal and as indicating cerebral oedema, respectively. In one patient, finally, a burr-hole was made at the wrong site. Strictly speaking this patient should not come under the heading non-surgical patients’. In these 3 patients the postmortem revealed an epidural haematoma without marked evidence of contusion. DISCUSSION The study presented here has the disadvantages of material analysed in retrospect; material, moreover, which comprises data recorded by many different physicians. But in view of the relatively rare occurrence of epidural haematoma, in only about 30/o of all head injuries, a prospective study would have to cover a long period (about 10 years). In the literature such a study is to be found only with regard to cerebral injuries in general (OVERGAARD, HVID-HANSEN, LAND, PEDERSEN, CHRTS'TANSEN,HAASE,HEIN and TWEED, 1973; JENNETT, 1972). Our study has shown that each of the following factors relates to an unfavourable prognosis: depth of coma, presence of extensor spasms, bilateral pupillary stiffness; bilateral pyramidal symptoms, areflexia, a pulse rate exceeding 1OO/min.. absence of a free interval and a more advanced age (over 50). The absence of a free interval is generally indicative of an intradural lesion (cerebral contusion, with or without acute subdural haematoma). The free interval was absent in 16 of the 24 patients with an intradural lesion. The very high mortality intradural over age 50 is based lesions (table 6). on, among other things, the higher frequency of The total mortality in this series was 370/o and the mortality after operation was 320/o. In patients who underwent an operation within 24 hours of the accident the mortality was as high as 500/o (fig. II). The total mortality in our series exceeds that in any other series published in the literature since 1960 (table 6). An explanation does not seem to lie in the higher frequency of intradural lesions, which is generally reported as 15-250/o. In any case the exactness of these data seems but relative, because anatomical verification cannot always have taken place. 111 addition, the mortality depends on the age distribution and on the interval between accident and operation (table 1). JOSEPHSON (1962), MCLAURIN and FORD (1964) reported a mortality of 60’)/,, within the first 6-8 hours, and of 250/o after the first 8 hours. 242 TABLE 6 Mortality of the epidural hematoma. Data from literature period no. of patients died after operation intradural lesion at operation 1949-1959 125 23% I 1 Y,;, 1916-1961 71 23% 25:/;, 1957-1962 115 19% 199;, 1956-1967 167 15.6% 47.3 % Bock et al. (1973) Vienna 19641971 65 20% ? Jonker and Oosterhuis (1976) Dept. Neurosurg. Neurol. Wilhelmina Gasthuis, Amsterdam 1961-1973 100 32% 16% McKissock et al. (1960) Neurosurg. Dept. St. Georg’s Hosp., London Heyser and Weher (1961) Neurochirurg. Klinik Ziirich Philips and Azariah (1965) South Western Neurosurg. Unit., Bristol Jamieson and Yelland (1965) Dept. Neur. Neurosurg. Royal Brisbane Hosp., Queensland (Austr.) B&K, BRENNER and W~~BER (1973) reported a total mortality of 200/o, Z/l8 patients dying after an operation within 12 hours of the accident and 6/19 after operations performed 12-24 hours after the accident. It is not immediately clear why the time interval within the first 24 hours did not influence the chance of survival in our series {fig. II). It may be that the interval between accident and operation is not relevant, but rather the interval between the not readily traceable first symptoms of cerebral compression and the operation. When ‘the symptoms of cerebral compression are rapidly progressive, the chance of survival is of course smaller when the patient is not in a (neuro)surgical centre. In this context it may be mentioned that 330/o of the patients showed symptoms of compression (extensor spasms and/or stiff pupils) before the operation; in the series of PHILIPS and AZARIAH(1965) and JAMIESONet al. (1968) these symptoms were observed in 210/o and 14.50/o of patients, respectively. The JAMIESONseries moreover, comprised only surgical patients. There may have been more patients with severe symptoms of compression in whose cases operation was refrained from. Although the published series are not readily comparable, the relatively high mortality in our series would seem to be determined in part by the large percentage of patients with compression symptoms and the large percentage of patients (710/o) who had to be operated on within 24 hours of a rapidly developing haematoma. 243 Of the patients transported over a distance exceeding 25 km, 7 died although the prognosis was considered to be fair as transport started. Since the mortality in our patients operated on after more than 24 hours was zero, comparison with other series can really only be made if the material is divided on the basis of this criterion. According to HOOPER (1959) a mortality of over 250,$ in patients with an epidural haematoma indicates faulty management and treatment; he maintains that the unavoidable mortality is only lO”/o. Apparently the situation in Amsterdam and the surrounding region of the Province of North-Holland has been less than optimal. In any case, only one of the patients transported to Amsterdam had been given a decompressing burr-hole by a general surgeon at ‘the site of first aid a procedure recommended by such authors as PHILIPS et al.(1965). Epidural haematoma is probably less quickly diagnosed when the free interval described as characteristic, is absent. This was the case in 47 patients of our series (table 2). They included on the one hand 13 patients without a lowering of the sensory level after initial loss of consciousness, all whom were operated on more than 24 hours later, and on the other hand the group with other intradural lesions. MCKISSOCK et al. (1960) observed a free interval in only 50 of his 125 patients. For the sake of completeness it should be pointed out that a free interval occurs also in cerebral fat embolism (usually 12-24 hours) and in so-called infantile contusion in which cerebral oedema develops a few hours after a sometimes slight head injury. Differential diagnosis from epidural haematoma can be difficult in such cases. Absence of a cranial fracture has been found to improve the prognosis substantially (table 5). Thi,s also applies to patients under 30. In this respect our findings corroborate GALBRAITH'S (1973) conclusion from a study of the literature that 910/o of patients with an epidural haematoma without cranial fracture were under age 30. It is conceivable that under that age the efasticity of the skull gives less marked local deformation, as a result of which on the one hand less force is exerted on the cerebrum, while on the other hand the lesion of the middle meningeal artery is less severe {FORD and MCLAURIN, 1963; P A, 1964). Absence of a crania1 fracture was not more frequent in patients not operated on within 24 hours. These data indicate that a diagnosis of epidural haematoma in patients under 30 cannot be excluded on the basis of absence of cranial fracture. A 24-hour observation period therefore seems advisable in all patients under 30 admitted with a head injury. It seems likely, although not statistically demonstrable in this material, that immediate surgical intervention is sensible even when serious symptoms of compression of the brain stem (stiff pupils, extensor spasms) are already present. This applies in particular to patients under 30. Even the time required for arteriography can be fatal to the patient in this situation. JAMIESON et al. (1968) in fact entirely omitted radiological examination of the skull in a large proportion of his patients. BoCK, BRENNER and WGBER (1972), OR the other hand, maintained that burr- 244 holes without preceding carotid angiography may be made only in extreme cmc‘rbecause there is a risk that the haematoma is missed. In our series ‘chronic’ epidural haematomas proved to carry a good prognosis, although diagnosis and operative treatment might take place after days to weeks. The residual morbidity after the later operations did not exceed that after acute operations (24 hours after the accident). Again it is difficult to decide whethet the data in the literature are comparable. MCKISSOCK et al. (1960) reported 130/u mortality after 24 hours, ~AM~ESON el al. (1968) reported 80/o; of his patients, 45oi0 were operated on after 24 hours. B&x et al. (1973) operated on 27164 patients after 24 hours: 4 died. The borderline between acute and non-acute therefore seems to be an arbitrary one; in any case the literature shows no agreement on this point. SPARACIO. KWATIB, CHXJ and COOK (1972) counted the first 48 hours as acute phase; HEYSEK and WEBER (1964) counted the first 7 days as such. MCKISSOCK et al. (1960), PHILIPS et al. (1965) and JAMIESON et al. 1968) made no distinction between acute and chronic, and reported a gradually decreasing mortality with an increasing interval between accident and operation. The very favourable course in our 27 patients who were operated on after 24 hours is therefore somewhat exceptional. gencies, The morbidity 7 patients assisted. in the 58 survivors showed B&K moderately residual et al. (1973) with a follow-up symptoms also severe residual symptoms was relatively of any significance, reported that 200/o low. Only but could of their walk patients un- showed but were able to walk, and that none showed akinetic mutism. ACKNOWLEDGEMENTS: We thank Prof. Dr. W. Noordenbos, Dr. L. v. Trotsenburg and Prof. Dr. W. A. den Hartog Jager for their critical comments. REFERENCES BtiK, F., BRBNNERH. and WijBER,0. (1972) Welche Maasnabmen kiinnen die Ergebnisse beim epiduralen Wimatom verbessern? Mschr. Unfallheilk, 75,408. B&K, F., BRENNER, H. and WaBER, G. (1973) Zur Symptomatologie und Prognose der traumatischen epiduralen Blutungen. Mschr. Unfailheilk. 76, 300. FORD, L. E. and MCLAURIN, R. L. (1963) mechanisms of extrad~al hematomas. J. neurosurgery 20, 760. GALBRAITH, s. L. (1973) Age-distribution of extradural hemorrhage without skull fracture. Lancet I, 1217. HEYSER, J. and WEBER,G. (1964) Die epiduralen Hlmatome. Schweiz. med. Wschr. I, 2. HOOPER, R., (1959) Observations on extradural hemorrhage. Brit. J. Surg. 47, 71. JAMIESON,K. G. and YELLAND,J. D. N. (1968) Extradural haematoma. Report of 167 cases. J. Neurosurgery 29, 12. JENNETT,B. (1972) Prognosis of severe head injury. Clin. Neurosurg. 19,200. JOSEPHSON, s. (1962) Epidural haematoma. A lo-year series. Acta chir. stand. 12#,26, MCKISSOCK, w., TAYLOR,J. c., BLOOM, W. H. and TILL, K. (1960) Extradurat haematoma. Observations on 125 cases. Iancet II, 167. 245 MCLAURIN, R. L., FORD, L. E. (1964) Extradural OVERGAARD, J., HVID-HANSEN, 0. LAND, haematoma. A., PEDERSEN, J. Neurosurg. 21, 364. K. K., CHRISTANSEN, S., HAASE, J., and TWEED, w. J. (1973) Prognosis after head injury based on early clinical examination. Lancet II, 631. PHILIPS, D. G. and AZARIAH, R. c. s. (1965) Acute intracranial haematoma from head injury: A study in prognosis. Brit. J. Surg. 52, 218. PIA, H. w. (1964) Die traumatische Hirnblutingen des Kindesalters. Acta Neurochir. II, 582. SPARACIO, R. R., KHATIB, R., CHILI, J. and COOK, A. w. (1972) Chronic epidural haematima. J. Trauma 12, 435. HEIN, o.